Over the weekend, I posted something on social media that wasn’t OK.
It was over on Instagram, and I shared this photo of a page from a book on writing and publishing.
I used the caption ‘Time to stop being submission type 2 #writing #editing #moralsupport #sofullofdoubt #writersofinstagram
Six people liked the post before one commented ‘that’s so ableist’.
As soon as I saw the comment I knew what it was referring to, and I was mortified. Any ideas?
That would be the appropriation of OCD to make a cheap joke.
Y’see kids, checking and re-checking a manuscript before sending it anywhere is just what all writing advice tells you to do. Losing confidence in your work and feeling like you can’t do anything with it for four years (or thereabouts) is a standard part of the writing process. Occasionally feeling paralysed by self doubt is a part of basically any creative process you can think of.
Obsessive Compulsive Disorder, on the other hand, is a debilitating mental illness. This article by Gabby Hutchinson Crouch explains in detail why this joke is predictable, lazy and a pain in the arse to anyone who actually has OCD. Please do read it.
Before You Wreck Yourself
So, having been called out, what did I do? Well, I spiralled a little bit to be honest. Here are the steps I went through.
- I was shocked and embarrassed.
- I got defensive. I started making excuses, e.g. ‘I am not ableist and I’m quite sure the author isn’t either, this was poor phrasing but written at a point before this dialogue was really becoming mainstream and was not intended to harm’.
- To note – the intention behind the words is irrelevant in this context. And as a writer, you should be able to express yourself without making light of the experiences of the 741,504 people living with OCD in the UK (1.2% of the population).
- I got annoyed. I knew I should delete the post, but I felt like doing so was some admission of ableism. And also 6 friends had liked it without spotting the problem, so shouldn’t I use this as way to educate them?
- I spoke this out loud to my husband, who fought bravely to find a diplomatic way of pointing out this was the defensiveness talking.
- I deleted the post.
- I messaged the person who called me out to thank them.
- I went for a walk, and stewed a bit.
- I thought about writing a blog post, because writing helps me process things.
- I wondered whether publishing said blog post would help by explaining this to a few folk who’d never thought about it before, or whether it would just seem like virtue signalling.
Clearly I posted it regardless.
Why am I telling you this?
I don’t know if you’ve ever come across the phrase ‘check your privilege’. If not, Hadley Freeman defined it in the Grauniad a few years ago as:
a way of telling a person who is making a political point that they should remember they are speaking from a privileged position because they are, for example, white, male, heterosexual, able-bodied or wealthy.
I know a couple of people that find it problematic, and think it’s used to censor or silence. My feeling though, is that all it’s asking you to do is engage a bit of empathy.
So for example as a white woman, my experience of travelling to America a few years ago was markedly different that of an Asian man. He is far more likely to be searched, cross questioned, and regarded with suspicion than I am. If in doubt, do read this by actor Riz Ahmed.
As a woman, I am more likely to be yelled at by a strange man if I have the audacity to walk past a building site. This last happened to me about a year ago, and was a ‘compliment’ paid only to me – all the men walking past on a busy street during lunch hour were left alone.
And as a person with no mental health issues, my experience of getting ready to query a book is nothing like that of someone battling OCD.
Does it take anything away from me to acknowledge that I experience the world differently from other people, and that in some ways I am very lucky? No it does not. Does it benefit anyone if I appropriate other people’s painful experiences for laughs? Clearly not. Checking your privilege isn’t censorship, it’s merely a way to not to be an arse.
I’ve said on here before that to be a decent writer, empathy is massively important. I would advocate the odd privilege check on that basis alone. Also if you’ve got any remote interest in publishing you’ll be aware of the issues around class, gender and race representation so again, check yourself before you wreck yourself.
Language can be used to engage, educate and inspire, but it can also be used to create barriers and make people feel crappy. Words have power. Think before you post, don’t encourage lazy punchlines, try to do better.
Take criticism on the chin and try to learn from it.
October 17, 2017 at 1:20 pm
I’m glad you owned up to your mistake. It’s hard to do, especially when you didn’t realize you had done something that could hurt someone else. And thank you for pointing out how harmful the passage is too – I don’t think I would’ve noticed the first time around.
October 23, 2017 at 9:17 am
Hi Ali. Great post. One small thought on your “My feminism will be intersectional or it will be bullshit” badge. I agree totally with the concept but I hate the term intersectional. It is an obscure term which hardly anybody understands for a really simple concept that everybody could understand! Surely someone can come up with a better word?! I’m worried (maybe it is just me being a linguist and all that) that progressive people are increasingly going down rabbit holes of increasingly complex terms, concepts and acronyms that few people on the outside can understand – even progressively minded and politically involved people! This is particularly the case with the American left.
October 23, 2017 at 9:27 am
Thanks for commenting! I don’t know, it’s been around since the 1980s (coined by Kimberlé Crenshaw, see the influence but of her wiki page https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kimberlé_Williams_Crenshaw) and nobody seems to have come up with a better alternative. I’d suggest it will get less obscure the more people understand and use it. Also is it really up to us to come up with a ‘better’ word than a black woman who has experienced lots of different isms you and I never will?
October 23, 2017 at 9:32 am
Good point Ali.
ls is it really up to us to come up with a ‘better’ word than a black woman who has experienced lots of different isms you and I never will?
Ha haI should check my privileges 🙂 Keep up the good work.